top of page

Who Leads the Maestro?

20 minutes ago
6 min read

This is an absolutely true story, except for the parts that are false.

The musical work that follows is already the third piece on the programme. Even if the Maestro wanted to make up a little for the late start of the concert by performing it at a faster tempo, he could not do so in this piece, thought some of those in the audience. For the Maestro himself is also "conducted", even when he gives the most rigorous of his performances. This work lasts exactly 4'33", 273" if we want to be more precise. To the surprise of some, and although the Maestro sketches his typical gestures, the ensemble¹ does not react. Not a sound is heard, or rather, no sound is heard from a musical instrument. A seat creaks and, further away, one senses someone embarrassed at not having managed to hold back a little "atishoo". On stage, the Maestro knows that this work by John Cage is a very original proposition. In fact, its aim is to make the audience hear all the sounds that usually occur during a concert but which nobody notices, precisely because everyone is concentrating on the music. The ensemble will not play a single note in the performance of this work. Needless to say, it is also a work that is different every time it is performed, since the sounds of the audience are never the same.


On the Maestro's music stand, from some angles of the stalls, something more could be seen besides his usual score, which, strangely, was itself practically blank, without staves and bearing only the indication tacet². But what could be seen from those angles was... a watch? The more knowledgeable noticed that the Maestro had consulted it before his first, restrained gesture. Without understanding why, they also sensed a certain unease in the Maestro. They know that the Maestro has to consult his watch religiously to ensure the best performance of this work by John Cage, a contemporary composer. It is his watch that guarantees him the rigorous timing of this work's duration. His watch marks the exact seconds, one after the other, with fantastic exactness and rigour, always with the same calm. For the Maestro, who is also a lover of watchmaking, it is even relaxing and soothing to admire how it works. Especially at the end of the more stressful days. Even more so if it were a Jaeger-LeCoultre Atmos³, with its mere two oscillations per minute, like the one the Maestro had seen in the workshop of his friend, the master watchmaker who carries out the meticulous servicing of his watches – not many, but much loved.

Jaeger-LeCoultre Atmos - REF. Q5135204

For this musical work, the Jaeger-LeCoultre Atmos, which had almost hypnotised him, would not do, not only because of its size on top of his music stand, but mainly because it makes only two soothing beats per minute, whereas 60 beats per minute (bpm) are required to perform this piece, whose name is precisely an indication of time: four minutes and thirty-three seconds, 4'33".


THE MASTER AND THE MAESTRO

Palmer Cadenzia pocket metronome, 1970s


As he goes on conducting the ensemble, or, if you prefer, gesticulating, he recalls the conversations with his friend and master watchmaker – who, thanks to him, has gradually been becoming a melomaniac⁴ – and who told him, in one of those conversations, that at least in this musical work the Maestro, too, has to remain faithful to 60 bpm, just like the watchmaker when he "tunes" his watch with the utmost rigour. In other words, in this work the Maestro is, he too, conducted. Half in jest, his friend had once told him that while a watchmaker strives to keep the seconds exact, one after the other, at a cadence of sixty per minute, musicians divide or multiply them. Not bad for a recent melomaniac, thought the Maestro, since in the musical repertoire, generally speaking, pieces at 60 bpm are not plentiful. A march, for example, as a rule has 120 bpm, and there are also tempos slower than 60 bpm, and so on. But there must undoubtedly be a basis, he thought, and that is precisely 60 bpm. Those who provide us with that basis are watches and clocks, rigorously maintained by his friend.



THE METRONOME AND THE WALL CLOCK


In fact, the Maestro had never thought much about this question, because the various tempos, from so many recordings and performances he had already heard, had become almost innate, making it practically unnecessary to consult the metronome. After some reasoning on the subject and a few conversations with his friend, he concluded that the metronome really does have many similarities with the workings of a wall clock. The similarities come from the fact that both have a rod and a bob, besides sharing a similar source of energy, the mainspring, and a similar gear train. Once again his watchmaker friend is right: whereas the bob in a wall clock serves to keep it at an exact frequency, in the metronome the aim is precisely to make the different frequencies heard, by adjusting the bob along the graduated scale of its rod, so that one can hear 60 bpm, 120 bpm, 180 bpm, 240 bpm, etc.


MUSICIANS VS WATCHMAKERS


Could musicians be villains who disturb the regularity so sought after by watchmakers? At this thought he smiled faintly and let out a little laugh. Oops, it was not the moment; he had just made his own involuntary sound contribution to John Cage's piece. In the almost absolute silence of the piece, hearing the Maestro let out a little laugh was somewhat compromising; perhaps he had let his thoughts fly a little too high, and so it happened. He quickly forgot the incident and returned to metronomes, recalling that watchmakers have also come up with pocket metronomes, such as the Patek Philippe & Co., Genève, Case no. 2 of 1880, which he had seen in his watchmaker friend's workshop and had asked to borrow to show his musician friends, since this pocket metronome beats 120 bpm. More recent is the Cadenzia metronome, which was also designed specifically for musicians and which divides the minute into an even greater number of beats. So musicians cannot be those villains who fragment time, since watchmakers themselves have supplied, and continue to supply, pocket metronomes to musicians. In truth, what exists is a collaboration between the two.

PATEK PHILIPPE & CO, GENÈVE, CASE NO. 2, CIRCA 1880

How wonderful it must be to own this Patek Philippe metronome, and one with elements alluding to music at that, since it bears the score of a melody on its dial. That melody is a mystery. No one has yet managed to discover which melody it is. People had even hummed it and recorded it. It is a beautiful melody, although, metrically, and for lack of any explanation, it must be considered to have a few small "slips" that only musicians notice. On the other hand, perhaps these slips may add even more value to the watch. What a great friend, he thought, to entrust him with a Patek Philippe just to try to discover the origin of that melody and, at the same time, to prove to other musicians that master watchmakers also remember the world of music, building desirable pocket metronomes.



GRAND FINALE


Bulova Accutron Spaceview and chiming clock


Perhaps there is even more between watchmaking and music than one might initially imagine. Chiming wall clocks, for example, usually delight us with two melodies: the Westminster and the Ave Maria. He also recalls the famous Bulova Accutron and its tuning fork of 300 Hz or 360 Hz. Now, the tuning fork is precisely an accessory used in music to help with tuning, and in music 300 Hz has a name: it is called D, while 360 Hz is called F sharp⁵. Those must have been the musical notes that Bulova owners heard when, at night, they left them directly on their bedside table and forgot to put a cloth underneath so that their sleep would not be disturbed. This thought leads the Maestro to sketch another smile, this time more disguised and restrained. When his thoughts wanted to keep flowing in search of new examples of what the worlds of watchmaking and music share, he realised that exactly 4’33” had passed. Had the piece ended? It had all been so quick. Had the audience given up 273” for nothing? Certainly not. As with the Maestro, a great deal had also gone on in the minds of the audience. Indeed, is that not also the purpose of this piece, to make us reflect a little in a different context? As he turned to acknowledge the applause, the Maestro caught sight of his watchmaker friend in the audience and also realised that his friend had seen the Patek Philippe he had lent him, sitting on top of his music stand. Since the Patek Philippe beats 120 bpm, did the Maestro count 546 beats to keep to the duration of this piece? His watchmaker friend wondered.


To be continued…




Notes

1- Ensemble - A musical group made up of an undefined number of members. Usually more than 10 members, but smaller than a band or an orchestra.

2 – tacet – Term indicating that the musician must remain silent, without playing.

3 – Atmos - Jaeger-LeCoultre

4 – Melomaniac – Someone who loves music

5 – Sharp (#) – Applied to a musical note, it raises its pitch to a slightly higher sound.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page