Study: The Social Standing of Brands

On 25 April, researchers Déborah Philippe, Alain Debenedetti, Damien Chaney, published an article entitled: “How brands mobilise status, reputation and trust cues to signal their social standing: the case of luxury watchmaking” This is not as common a study as one might think. A total of 420 magazine advertisements and 36 watch brands were analysed over a period of 4 years. It also explored how brands drew on social status, reputation and trust to raise their own social standing and thereby attract customers.
This is a translation of the article published by Déborah Philippe, Alain Debenedetti, Damien Chaney; the full study can be consulted at the following link:
Philippe, D., Debenedetti, A., & Chaney, D. (April 25, 2022). How brands mobilize status, reputation, and legitimacy cues to signal their social standing: The case of luxury watchmaking. Marketing Theory.
Reading this article is very useful for anyone who intends to create a watch brand, as well as for all consumers curious enough to lift the curtain on watchmaking marketing. Marketing works like a play made up of sets, stories and actors. In this specific case, the play is about a struggle to simplify consumers’ decisions in situations where little information is available about the value of commercial exchanges.
Introduction
A company’s social standing in itself already conveys some information about its quality and value; however, companies are able to shape markets and influence their social standing. Although there is growing interest in the study of companies’ social positions on these matters, the proposal of researchers Déborah Philippe, Alain Debenedetti and Damien Chaney is to explore the potential of social evaluations to shed light on how brands make sense of their embeddedness and their trajectories in the market. They also propose to explore brands’ ability to influence perceptions of their social value from an integrative perspective (that is, drawing on different dimensions), rather than focusing on one specific social evaluation, which would mean missing the opportunity to explore contrasting or combined effects.
In this study, the authors investigate how brands strategically mobilise and leverage different dimensions of their social standing in their communication in order to shape consumers’ perceptions. They explore this question in the context of the fine watchmaking market, which is an interesting setting for two reasons: it is part of the luxury field, in which highlighting social standing is particularly important; and it is a rich and complex market populated by different types of actors or brands, which entered it at different stages. A content analysis of magazine advertisements from 36 watch brands allowed them to identify four ways of mobilising and combining certain aspects of status, reputation and trust. They also found that these strategies are not left solely to the brands’ discretion, but also depend on their embeddedness in the market. Finally, their findings also suggest nuances in the way luxury brands communicate.
Status
The construct of “status” has been widely studied in fields such as sociology and social psychology. Status refers to the socially constructed, intersubjectively agreed position that an actor occupies within a social structure. It serves as an evaluation of that actor’s worth based on the possession of discriminating characteristics, that is, characteristics associated with general expectations of superior or inferior ability. Status is fundamentally honorific, since it elicits deference and tribute, and generates privilege.
Higher-status actors benefit not only from easier conditions but also from greater rewards than their lower-status counterparts.
Existing research suggests, for example, that high-status organisations are more likely to enjoy lower transaction costs, greater returns on quality investments, and reduced pressure to conform to social norms and expectations.
Reputation
The concept of reputation is inherited from game theory and refers to the beliefs of various audiences, built up over time, about the likelihood that the organisation will be valued along specific dimensions. These beliefs are founded on various observations of the quality of past products or characteristics, which serve as indicators of present and future quality. Reputation therefore reflects underlying quality and differences between organisations and, as such, constitutes a perceptual representation of a company’s past actions and future prospects.
Because reputation represents how well a specific organisation performs relative to its competitors, market participants rely on it for a wide range of decisions, such as investment or career decisions, as well as product choices.
Enjoying a favourable reputation is therefore associated with benefits such as greater customer retention, better consumer–brand relationships, a greater ability to charge premium prices, and a better perception of the brand’s products.
A better reputation makes it possible to increase sales, market value and product prices.
Trust
Trust has been a central theme in sociological studies. Trust refers to a socially constructed sense of appropriateness and to the endorsement of an organisation by social actors, based on the perception or assumption that the organisation’s actions are desirable, proper or appropriate.
An organisation is considered legitimate when consumers believe that it seeks to achieve socially acceptable goals in a socially acceptable way.
While not being, or not appearing, trustworthy incurs penalties, being or appearing trustworthy brings multiple advantages. Some organisational research has shown how being trustworthy increases an organisation’s ability to acquire resources and, even, its chances of future survival.
Trust can lead to stronger consumer support, increased purchase intentions, better returns on new products, and greater efficiency of marketing channels in international markets.
As organisations seek legitimacy to ensure their stability and survival, they adopt structures and practices that can help them secure this social approval.
The distinctive properties of social evaluations
Status, reputation and trust significantly influence market actors’ perceptions of an actor’s worth, as well as their willingness to exchange resources with that actor. As such, they share a number of common characteristics. For example, status and legitimacy both imply acts of social acceptance. Likewise, reputation and trust are based on evaluations of whether an actor meets expectations and, since both are multidimensional constructs, the same organisational attributes or characteristics can be used to assess both reputation and trust.
Although status, reputation and trust share common characteristics, they differ in their underlying mechanisms. Reputation judgements are based on observing an organisation’s past quality and behaviour and are driven by a mechanism of differentiation. They focus on the differences between organisations with regard to specific characteristics and involve comparisons between organisations. Status judgements are based on the organisation’s possession of desirable attributes or characteristics. They rely on social restriction and are driven by a mechanism of distinction. This mechanism of distinction is associated with notions of exclusivity, prestigious position and hierarchy, in contrast with the neutral mechanism of differentiation underlying reputation judgements.
Like reputation, status judgements involve comparisons, but the antecedents and the evaluation mechanisms are different. Since trust judgements are based on observing the organisation’s conformity with norms and values considered desirable, they are driven by a mechanism of alignment. Whereas reputation and status make an organisation stand out, trust relies on more inclusive mechanisms, since meeting expectations implies some degree of convergence in organisational behaviour.
Aim of the study
Few, if any, empirical studies have investigated how actors or brands jointly mobilise all three social evaluations. More importantly, marketing research has not yet fully explored the potential of a strategic use of these different evaluations in brand communication.
These authors’ research therefore aims to fill this gap by investigating how brands can strategically mobilise and deploy cues related to these social evaluations in order to build their image and increase their overall appeal.
Context
The authors investigated how brands use social evaluation cues in their communication strategies in the context of the luxury industry. The luxury industry was considered suitable because it is an industry in which signalling social standing is particularly important. Luxury brands differ from other types of brands because they follow a logic rooted in their sociological characteristics that is fundamentally different from that of mass-market brands. As a market involving the “economics of singularity”, its goods and services are multidimensional, incommensurable and valued on the basis of highly subjective evaluations.
Within the luxury industry, the authors chose to focus on the fine watchmaking market, which provides an attractive setting in which to explore the research question. Fine watchmaking is characterised by a perimeter that is hard to define, a wide range of technical features and a great variety of product prices. There is no clear definition of fine watchmaking (in contrast with, for example, haute couture, which refers to a legally defined designation).
The Fondation de la Haute Horlogerie, refers to fine watchmaking as “excellence in watchmaking, watchmaking techniques in symbiosis with the applied arts”,
a rather vague and subjective definition. Given this ambiguity, brands’ ability to signal their social standing is essential in helping consumers and other market actors to navigate the market.
Today, the watch market is largely dominated by Swiss brands, known for their watchmaking expertise. Swiss watchmaking was born at the beginning of the 17th century in two regions: Geneva and the Arc Jurassien, located around Lake Neuchâtel. Although Germany was the first nation to build miniaturised portable watches (around 1530), and the Swiss industry faced strong competition from the British, French and Dutch markets, Swiss watchmakers were behind many inventions during the 18th century (for example, the perpetual watch or the tourbillon).
Switzerland had a unique production system, called établissage, which consisted of dividing the production process among many independent entities owned by different specialised craftsmen, often with their own workshop at home, with the final product being assembled by the manufacturers at the end of the process. This system allowed the Swiss industry to retain its craft and traditional character while developing its watches at a much faster pace than its competitors. In 1850 Switzerland produced 10 times more watches than Great Britain (2,000,000 vs 200,000). Although Switzerland had little interest in mass production, Swiss watchmakers were forced to modernise their production processes at the end of the 19th century (owing to competition from the American market, which produced large quantities of cheaper watches), moving from their établissage process to a factory mode of production. The industrialisation of production with further mechanisation led to higher levels of productivity, while preserving the unique know-how of Swiss craftsmen.
The greatest challenge to Swiss supremacy came from the so-called quartz crisis, which took place between 1970 and 1980. The worldwide introduction of battery-powered quartz watches made mechanical watches obsolete and caused a major crisis in the Swiss industry, which was unprepared for the emergence of this new technology. The country quickly lost its competitive advantage, which led many Swiss manufacturers to reposition the Swiss watch industry towards the luxury, high-quality segment of the market and to restart the production of mechanical watches, which had almost been abandoned. By redefining and combining the values of craftsmanship, luxury and precision, they were able to rebuild the community of mechanical watchmakers and create demand for “exceptional watches”. By 2008, the Swiss mechanical watch industry had re-emerged to become the world’s leading exporter of watches (in monetary value), thus re-establishing its global dominance.
Data collection, coding and analysis
The authors’ objective was to understand how watch brands signal their social standing in customer-oriented communication, and
the authors collected and analysed all the print advertisements published by 36 watch brands in French magazines between 2011 and 2014.
According to the authors, “advertising is one of the main instruments that luxury companies can leverage to confer meaning on their brands.” Magazines are an ideal vehicle for communicating about high-quality technical products that may require detailed information, and France is well known for its rich magazine press, which actively showcases luxury products, including watches. The authors collected data at brand level, consistent with marketing communication practices at customer level.
Data collection unfolded in several stages. First, an online platform that lists, illustrates and categorises all advertising campaigns in the French market was consulted. With the help of a Media Manager, 137 French magazines that published watch advertisements during the 2011–2014 period were selected, and 164 watch brands included in the database were identified. Second, the data were reduced and the final sample was built according to the following cumulative criteria: (1) the brand’s presence on the lists provided by professional associations, such as the FHH; (2) the brand’s presence in high-end Parisian retail outlets (that is, the luxury watch areas of the main department stores, specialised high-end shops and exclusive boutiques). This stage resulted in the selection of 36 Swiss and non-Swiss brands, a sample that captures a diversity of actors in terms of size, founding date, geographical origin and type of ownership (independent vs. corporate group). Finally, the authors collected 8,209 entries for these 36 brands during the observation period, corresponding to a set of 420 unique communication units (each unit being reproduced in several magazines at the same time and/or over long periods).
Next, qualitative content analyses of these advertisements were carried out on the basis of their different textual elements (slogan/brand signature, main body text and subtext) and iconographic elements (images and iconic symbols). The authors’ aim was twofold: to identify whether and how the advertisements mobilised cues belonging to the repertoires of status, reputation or trust. A codebook was developed according to the theoretical definition of the three constructs and their underlying mechanisms, as well as their prior operationalisation in existing research in organisation theory, combined with the particularities of the watch industry, but the authors kept it open so that new codes could emerge during the coding process. Since status rests on a mechanism of distinction based on the possession of discriminating characteristics, the authors coded cues evoking notions of prestige and social esteem as belonging to the status repertoire. For example, as there is a long tradition of using awards, certifications or nominations as markers of status, the authors coded these references as status cues. Reputation is based on a mechanism of differentiation and signals the brand’s ability to consistently deliver high quality on criteria relevant to the focal market. Reputation evaluations are therefore based mainly on observing past performance in order to form expectations about future actions and performance. In the context of fine watchmaking, technical performance is the central quality criterion. Thus, the authors coded cues evoking performance (for example, technical references related to watchmaking, such as movements or complications, or broader evocations of performance, such as sporting champions) as belonging to the reputation repertoire. Finally, trust is based on a mechanism of alignment, which involves demonstrating that the brand conforms to the market’s fundamental norms and codes and embodies its values. The constitutive values and norms of watchmaking include, among others, identity (which refers to history and geography), authenticity and mastery. Cues referring to the brand’s DNA, heritage or craftsmanship were therefore coded as belonging to the trust repertoire.

The first stage of the coding process consisted of identifying the presence versus absence (that is, a count) of trust, status and/or reputation cues for each advertisement, which provided initial insights into the number and type of cues mobilised by the watchmakers. Although useful, this first stage was not enough to develop a full understanding of the brands’ communication strategies. Advertisements are made up of many elements (for example, images, brand names, slogans, texts and subtexts) that have different visual impacts. It follows that the cues differed in their prominence and signalling power. For example, although Chanel’s 2011J12 advertisement includes a trust cue, stating that the watch’s movement is produced by Audemars Piguet, the information is placed in an almost invisible footnote. By contrast, when Vacheron Constantin stresses how legitimate the brand is, it does so through a detailed narrative that forms the central element of the advertisement. In the second stage of the coding process, the analysis was refined by considering the prominence of the different cues within each advertisement, in order to provide a more nuanced analysis.
Although each brand’s communication was initially coded separately, the authors quickly discovered patterns in the use of social evaluation cues across the whole sample (that is, what appeared to be distinct strategies). After analysing the whole sample, the brands were grouped into different categories according to the strategies identified. This process led to the identification of four groups of brands that differed in their market characteristics and in their use of social evaluation cues. Table 2 presents the list of the different brands, and Table 3 provides the coding scheme and the textual and pictorial illustrations of the codes.

Table 3. Coding scheme.

The authors ensured the internal validity of the coding process by means of a double-coding procedure. The codebook was developed by the first authors of the study during the first coding stage. These two authors jointly coded the data set. Then two trained assistants independently coded the entire data set to identify the presence or absence of cues, using the codebook provided. The authors then compared the two sets of coding and obtained an inter-rater agreement kappa statistic of 0.94, which indicates substantial agreement between the two coders. Each instance of discrepant coding was discussed collectively until agreement was reached. The second coding stage was handled by the first two authors.
Results
By investigating the dynamics of the fine watchmaking market, the analysis revealed two main findings. First, evidence was found that brands use social evaluation cues as strategic resources (that is, resources that can be leveraged to build and maintain a competitive advantage) to develop stories about the brands and their social standing in the fine watchmaking market. Four groups of brands were identified, each with distinct stories that mobilise and combine the three repertoires of status, reputation and trust in a different way.
Second, the authors found that these strategic resources are not necessarily equally available to all market actors, since some brands were more constrained than others in building their social positioning. Specifically, a pattern was found in the construction of these stories, such that the use of the three repertoires or their combination was not left solely to the brand’s discretion, but also depended on the brand’s embeddedness in the market.
Economic sociology posits that markets are socially embedded; that is, economic actors are embedded, to varying degrees, in the social relations and affiliations that shape their opportunities for value creation. Actors’ embeddedness has been defined and operationalised in different ways. In this study, the authors examined how brands are spatially and temporally situated in the focal market of fine watchmaking. A brand’s spatial embeddedness is determined by the extent to which watchmaking represents a core (vs. peripheral) activity: the greater the importance of watchmaking relative to the brand’s other activities (if any) in its portfolio, the greater its spatial embeddedness. A brand’s temporal embeddedness is determined by the length of the brand’s presence in the market: the longer it has been active in the market, the greater its temporal embeddedness.
It was found that the extent of these brands’ embeddedness shapes their ability to signal their social standing and to access the related repertoires. These findings are discussed in detail in the following subsections. Figure 1 shows the four groups by market embeddedness and illustrates the different uses of social evaluation cues, taking into account their visibility and recurrence (that is, overall prominence) in the brands’ advertisements. Figure 2 provides examples of the different types of stories conveyed in these advertisements.
Figure 1. Representation of the four groups and their discursive strategies according to their market embeddedness.

Figure 2. Illustrations of the different types of advertisements and their coding.

Historical brands: Guardians of the fine watchmaking heritage
The first and largest group of brands includes the historical actors of the market. These brands’ communication focuses on showing the brand’s ability to make traditional watches and emphasises the heritage and the know-how of the brand. They present themselves as guardians of the watchmaking heritage. To do so, they build a story that rests mainly on the abundant mobilisation of cues from the trust repertoire, accompanied and reinforced by some cues from the status and reputation repertoires. Interestingly, most status cues are mobilised to interact with trust cues (and with the notion of tradition in particular), while asserting the brands’ uniqueness and desirability. Although present, the reputation repertoire remains largely in the background. Also notable within this group is the consistency of textual and pictorial elements within each brand.
The tradition component of the story rests largely on the use of historical cues. The brand’s founding date, frequently mentioned, systematically refers to the 18th and 19th centuries, as in “founded in 1755” (Vacheron Constantin) or “since 1833” (Jaeger-LeCoultre), thereby emphasising the brand’s longevity. Brands also use temporal cues to emphasise their continuity:
“As a family-owned manufacturer, we are committed to restoring and maintaining all our watches. Including those made in 1839”
Temporal cues are often accompanied by spatial cues. The brands’ anchoring in Switzerland is prominently displayed in the advertisements, which allows them to emphasise their membership of the group of leading legitimate Swiss players. References to Switzerland, whether textual or iconographic, are often accompanied and reinforced by status cues mentioning specific and exclusive places in the country: Geneva (Patek Philippe and Jaquet Droz), with a photo of the lake and its water jet, a must-see attraction of the city; the Vallée de Joux (Jaeger-LeCoultre); or even a district on Lake Geneva, L'Ile (Vacheron Constantin). This strategy is also used by A. Lange & Söhne, one of the rare non-Swiss brands in the group. Although the brand cannot claim a Swiss identity, it refers directly to Glashütte, the well-known cradle of the German watch industry.
This combination of spatio-temporal cues is also complemented by numerous references to craftsmanship and authenticity.
The brands make abundant references to the maître horloger (master watchmaker), a professional term that emphasises the skills of the brand’s craftsmen and sends a strong signal of trust.
They also frequently mention manufacture, a specific high-status French term denoting the ability to master the design of a watch from A to Z. This status cue helps to reinforce the brand’s trust with regard to its craftsmanship. These prominent, industry-specific semantic elements are also accompanied by references to more general notions, such as tradition, atelier, savoir-faire or métier d'art (craftsmanship), suggesting that watchmaking lies at the intersection of craft and art. These discursive elements are supported by a specific iconography: Vacheron Constantin illustrates the closeness of craft and art with an image showing the hand of a craftsman working on a piece inspired by Chagall’s fresco at the Paris Opera; others show an image of the watch’s mechanical parts to complement their discourse, such as Patek Philippe: “Our 175 years of experience in Haute Horlogerie, at the heart of our family company’s heritage, allow us to design some of the most elegant and complicated watches ever made” (2014). All these cues highlighting the longevity and the long-established know-how of historical brands are mobilised to convey a sense of authenticity and to help the audience distinguish “the real thing” from its copies.
To complement this abundance of trust cues, some brands in this group also borrow from the status repertoire (in addition to the status cues mentioned above). Status cues help to signal the prestige derived from history and tradition, thus reinforcing the brand’s trust as a central, historical actor of the market. The brands emphasise their active participation in the history of watchmaking by displaying technical inventiveness or innovation, with expressions or signatures such as “Breguet, creator of the first wristwatch” (Breguet) or “Zenith, inventor of the high-frequency automatic chronograph” (Zenith). They also mention the brand’s relationship with prestigious historical figures, sometimes even using them as endorsers: Queen Marie-Antoinette (Jaquet Droz), the Russian tsar (Breguet), or the pilot and writer Antoine de Saint-Exupéry (IWC). Status is also displayed through the use of exclusive certifications, accessible only to a limited number of actors (for example, the Geneva Seal), prestigious awards or the organisation of retrospective exhibitions about the brand (for example, Girard-Perregaux).
Reputation cues are also present, but to a much lesser degree, as they are included mainly in footnotes and therefore remain in the background.
However, a subgroup of manufacturers (Audemars Piguet, IWC, Cartier and Chopard) explicitly emphasises the product’s “technical performance”, while some others mention patent registrations and affiliations with actors renowned for their performance.
For example, Breitling and Chopard emphasise their collaboration with well-known sports car brands, such as Bentley or Porsche. Reputation cues are also combined with status cues: when performance is staged through symbolic affiliations, it is mainly through references to “noble” sports (for example, golf, tennis, sailing and polo) or “extreme” sports/practices (for example, aviation, racing and diving).
This group’s communication strategy is made possible by the brands’ deep spatio-temporal embeddedness in the market, which is relatively consistent across the group. These brands are not only able to mobilise all three repertoires together, but are also able to leverage these social evaluations through a rich and interrelated set of meaningful cues. The story built and endorsed by this group is that of a brand that took part in the creation of the market, that is representative of its fundamental values and that derives prestige from it. The manufacture cue, omnipresent, for example, is both a sign of conformity with a central norm of fine watchmaking and a mark of distinction. All the cues of the trust repertoire are heavily mobilised to show perfect alignment with the audience’s expectations of good watchmaking and, as a side effect, possibly to minimise the legitimising efforts of less embedded (that is, more recent and peripheral) actors.
Notorious brands: Celebrating success and stardom
The second group of actors comprises better-known and more accessible (in terms of price) traditional brands.
These brands’ communication is fairly intensive and focuses mainly on building the idea that wearing a fine watchmaking watch confers status and success on consumers.
Mastery of the codes of fine watchmaking appears only in the background, in contrast with the first group, which bases its communication mainly on these elements. Their story is largely dominated visually by status cues and, to a lesser degree, by reputation cues. The target consumers are those eager to benefit from these brands’ prestige and performance, through an affiliation with famous brands that everyone can identify. In this group, the advertisements are less consistent than those of the traditional brands, probably because they target a wide range of consumers.
As its main means of conveying the idea of social distinction, this group relies heavily on affiliations with high-status, successful endorsers, partners or events.
For example, Omega’s affiliation with George Clooney rests on the actor’s “aura” in his field.
In many cases, the ambassadors, described as heroes, are chosen to express status and performance at their highest levels. In this story, performance is presented more as a social achievement than a personal one. Rolex’s 2014 “live for greatness” campaign, for example, celebrates (mainly) sports stars who have reached the highest position in their field of expertise. Besides being endorsed by prestigious sports or film stars, this group’s stardom also relies on partnerships with events or institutions in order to benefit from an aura in their domain: Tag Heuer is the “official partner” of the Monaco Grand Prix, one of the most prestigious Formula 1 races; Rolex emphasises its many prestigious official and unofficial partners in sport, from the Evian golf tournament to the Wimbledon tennis championships and Formula 1. What these events have in common is that they are systematically presented as the best/first/most exclusive events. For example, Rolex portrays the Oyster Perpetual Sky-Dweller with an image of Wimbledon’s Centre Court accompanied by the slogan: “This watch has witnessed historic matches on the Centre Court of one of the most prestigious tournaments in the world” (2014 campaign).
This use of highly successful endorsers is reinforced by semantic elements that help to express the brands’ ability to be the best in their field, to have been the first to accomplish a feat or to have witnessed historic moments. Breitling’s 2011 “Chronomat” advertisement illustrates this specific use of status cues:
“Breitling has shared in all the great hours of the conquest of the skies. ... In 1952 came the birth of the legendary Navitimer, followed by many other chronographs for the aces of the sky. Today, the favourite brand of pilots and aviation enthusiasts perpetuates this authentic and privileged bond by cooperating with the elite of aviators, directing several exceptional formations and partnering with the greatest air shows on the planet”.
Another means of conveying social distinction is to demonstrate the brand’s position as market leader through mentions of awards, innovation and pioneering behaviour. The brands in this group largely communicate distinction through awards at the GPHG (Grand Prix d'Horlogerie de Genève), the Oscars of the watch industry. Tag Heuer, for example, mentions the 2010 “prix de la petite aiguille”, an award given to the best watch under 5,000 euros. The watchmakers in this group also weave pioneering references into their communication, thus adding a touch of historical cues to their social discourse. Breitling and Tag Heuer notably point to their achievement as the first in an important watchmaking innovation: “The inventor of the modern chronograph” (Breitling, 2011) and “The first mechanical counter accurate to 1/100th of a second” (Tag Heuer, 2011).
The reputation repertoire is mobilised to express performance in the context of a wide variety of sports through a combination of specific semantic and pictorial elements that visually illustrate the idea of speed and precision, such as fighter jets (Breitling) or Formula 1 (Tag Heuer). This group of brands shares a market space similar to that of the first group, but with a somewhat smaller temporal dimension (on average, the brands are more recent). The breadth and depth of the mobilisation of the repertoires are relatively similar to those of the first group, even if the repertoires are leveraged in a different way. Much like the previous group of brands, which used a single cue to signal different meanings, some members of this group use ambassadors and endorsers in several ways.
For example, Rolex’s use of Roger Federer signals a connection with consistently high performance (thereby emphasising Rolex’s reputation), since the tennis icon broke every record and stayed at the top of the tennis hierarchy for many years (thereby conferring status on Rolex), and also with Switzerland, since Federer is a native of the country (indirectly conferring trust on the brand).
However, in contrast with the first group, which largely emphasises trust in its communication, in the second group the brands rely heavily on stories of stardom and success through the mobilisation of the status and reputation repertoires.
Contemporary brands: The quest for performance
The third group consists of “newcomers”, or brands (essentially Swiss and French) founded after the Second World War. The stories these brands create focus on highlighting product performance. They mainly mobilise the reputation repertoire through the depiction of mechanisms integrating a variety of functions (thereby emphasising the brand’s technological excellence), and through the use of images that evoke performance (often in connection with sports or activities in which timekeeping is crucial).
Trust cues are almost absent from these brands’ communication, while status cues are scarce and barely visible. This focus on performance contributes to the consistency of the advertisements within each brand’s communication and is displayed through technical arguments and images that evoke high performance.
A central element of these brands’ communication is the prominent and multiple mentions of technical features, such as the tourbillon, a watchmaking complication added to the escapement mechanism (Bell & Ross, Corum and Hublot), or a long power reserve for mechanical watches (Bell & Ross and Hublot). These technical elements are complemented by performance indicators and associated evocative images.
For example, Bell & Ross promotes its watch water-resistant to 500 metres, while Hublot notes that its LaFerrari model has a world-record power reserve of 50 days.
In addition to these relatively easy-to-understand technical terms (for example, chronometer, water resistance),
these brands tend to use complex terms that suggest the technicality of watch mechanics, but which only make sense to experts.
In the case of Richard Mille, these technical terms appear in the form of a long list (which looks like a sports car data sheet in a specialist magazine) and serve as the core of the advertisement’s message.
The images in the advertisements focus on evocations of motor sports and extreme activities, such as fighter-jet flight, in which the watch is presented as a high-performance tool accompanying an activity in which precision is vital and timekeeping plays an essential role. The generic images used often include a fighter plane (Bell & Ross), a racing car (Hublot), a motorbike (Bell & Ross), a diver (Bell & Ross) or a sailing boat (Corum). The advertisements also mention affiliations with sporting events (Corum and the Trophée Jules Verne), partnerships with a motor sport brand (for example, the partnership between Hublot and Ferrari) and even partnerships with military institutions (Bell & Ross with RAID or GIGN).
Showing the watch’s performance also involves mentions of certifications and labels. Although present in many advertisements in this group, these cues are less visible in the communication, as they are evoked mainly through pictograms and/or short texts in small print. Some brands promote the COSC label (Contrôle Officiel Suisse des Chronomètres), which certifies a “high level of precision and uniqueness of timekeeping instruments”, as well as “a guarantee of extreme quality”. As only Swiss brands can receive this label, this cue indirectly signals the brand’s legitimate membership of the watch market.
In contrast with the first two groups, these brands are only partially embedded in the market. They belong as core players (that is, they have spatial embeddedness in the market), but they lack the temporal depth of embeddedness of the historical players, which restricts their ability to mobilise the three repertoires, particularly trust.
Overall, almost no trust cues are present in these brands’ advertisements.
Some brands, however, mention specific geographical locations (for example, La Chaux de Fonds for Corum), as marks of distinction. As core players, however, they possess the technical expertise needed to build a competitive advantage in the market, which allows them to draw extensively on the reputation repertoire through a rich variety of cues that extol the technical complexity and performance of the watches. What they lack in breadth of repertoire is somewhat offset by the depth of their use of the reputation repertoire.
Haute couture, jewellery and accessories brands: lost in social evaluations
The fourth group comprises mainly luxury brands from the jewellery, fashion and accessories markets. Whether limited (for example, Dior) or successful (for example, Chanel) in terms of watch sales, these brands stand apart from the other three groups. Indeed, they are characterised by a rather simplistic, if not absent, discourse that only marginally evokes the codes of fine watchmaking. Their communication fails to build a consistent story (at group or brand level, except for Louis Vuitton), but uses scattered and mostly disconnected cues belonging to the status (mainly) and trust repertoires, without visibly mobilising the reputation repertoire. In most advertisements, the watch occupies the central part (if not all) of the advertising page, with no text or supported by footnotes in small print.
The brands make few or no references to the values and norms of fine watchmaking. For example, only Louis Vuitton indicates that its watches are produced in La Chaux de Fonds, one of the cradles of the Swiss watch industry.
Other brands, such as Van Cleef & Arpels, which has been producing watches for more than a century and can therefore qualify as a legitimate market actor temporally speaking, curiously do not capitalise on this fact or make any mention of their historical watchmaking experience.
Moreover, there are no iconographic elements that could help to anchor the haute couture and jewellery brands in the market and counterbalance the absence of trust elements in the discourse.
The status repertoire is superficially mobilised through the use of prestigious ambassadors. In most cases, however, and unlike the brand affiliation strategy of the historical brands group, these endorsers have no connection with the watch market, but appear to have been selected for their glamorous aura, such as Sophie Marceau for Chaumet and Charlize Theron for Dior. Moreover, although all these brands enjoy a high-status position in their home market, they make no attempt to transfer some of that prestige to the watch market. One exception is Van Cleef & Arpels, whose advertisements make direct references to the brand’s high status in high jewellery, its main market.
Some reputation cues are present, but almost invisible, and the technical features of the watches are, for the most part, not mentioned; if they are, it is only superficially.
This is partly due to the over-representation of women’s watches in this group and to the gender stereotypes of the watch market, which tends to associate performance with men’s watches and glamour with women’s watches.
Overall, the brands in this group make little use of the social evaluation repertoires, probably owing to their limited embeddedness in the market. In contrast with the other groups, whose membership is relatively homogeneous, the brands that fall into the fourth group are highly heterogeneous in terms of their temporal embeddedness, with significantly higher levels of temporal embeddedness for jewellery brands. For example, whereas Chaumet began making fine watches at the beginning of the 19th century and Van Cleef & Arpels at the beginning of the 20th century, Chanel only began its watchmaking activity in 1987 and Louis Vuitton in 2002. The extent of the group’s spatial embeddedness, however, is uniformly low, since their identity as jewellery or haute couture brands places them as peripheral actors in the market. Their limited overall embeddedness in the market significantly restricts their ability to leverage the social evaluation repertoires. In particular, it almost entirely prevents them from mobilising the trust repertoire, which the first group of brands displays so strongly. As peripheral market players, they also lack the technical expertise that would allow them to mobilise the reputation repertoire. Finally, although they can easily access the status repertoire (given their high-status position in their main markets), only a limited number of brands do so, and only superficially, through a limited set of cues. In contrast with the first group, which uses several complementary cues to signal its status in the market, this group of brands evokes social distinction through the use of famous and glamorous endorsers, in a strategy borrowed from their home market.
Theoretical contributions
The authors drew on the dynamic market systems approach to conceptualise status, reputation and trust as strategic resources that brands mobilise to signal their social standing in the market. As this approach suggests, markets are evolving into complex systems, rather than pre-existing stable structures. In line with this understanding of markets as dynamic systems, the authors’ research explores the dynamics underlying brands’ social standing and shows how brands are shaped by the complex social systems in which they are embedded and how they are able to actively shape them. By providing insights into how brands mobilise and organise social evaluation cues to influence audiences’ perceptions of their social standing, they add to the body of studies that treat social evaluations from a strategic angle, a perspective that would otherwise hardly be adopted in marketing research on social evaluations, which tends to focus on the benefits that brands can derive from their status, reputation or trust. More specifically, the authors’ contribution to the marketing literature is threefold.
First, in contrast with previous empirical work that tends to focus on a single evaluation and/or sometimes to conflate them, the authors developed an integrative perspective that considers and operationalises status, reputation and trust as distinct strategic resources that brands can deploy. In doing so, they shed some light on the underlying mechanisms of these evaluations, which in turn allowed them to identify distinct communication repertoires associated with status, reputation and trust.
These three repertoires differ in nature. For example, the trust repertoire is mainly context-specific, since norms and expectations are tied to the focal market (that is, the notion of spatio-temporal heritage or craftsmanship certainly matters in other markets of the luxury industry, but not so much in other industries). The reputation repertoire is less specific: whatever the industry, building a reputation relies on signalling the performance of the product or service; the form this performance takes, however, depends on the market in question. The status repertoire appears to be the least specific and the most fungible: although some cues are related to the market, others can be drawn from outside the focal market.
Second, the authors add to research focusing on the strategic use of social evaluations insights into how different types of brands use these repertoires differently. Specifically, the authors found different patterns in the way brands deploy and combine these repertoires in their communication to gain a competitive advantage: some brands use all three repertoires, some focus on a single one and others rely on none. Of particular interest is the way these repertoires are sometimes used in combination, to reinforce certain cues (for example, status cues being used to strengthen the visibility of trust-related elements, such as tradition or authenticity). These differences are partly due to the brands’ strategic intent, since there is some discretion in the way brands can use these resources to shape their position in the market, but they are also constrained by differentiated access to the repertoires. Specifically, they argue that the extent of a brand’s market embeddedness affects both the breadth and the depth of its mobilisation of these repertoires. Embedded actors can access all the repertoires and operationalise them in a large set of rich, meaningful and interconnected cues, whereas less embedded actors are more restricted in their access to repertoires and in their choice of cues, the latter being used more inconsistently and superficially.
In particular, the authors found that the trust repertoire is difficult (if not impossible) to mobilise for brands with little market embeddedness, such as jewellery, haute couture or accessories brands, and to a lesser degree for newcomers, who are more embedded and master the market’s codes but do not yet have the temporal depth of the historical actors.
Although the lack of heritage or market embeddedness is a significant obstacle for these brands in mobilising trust cues, the communication strategy of the brands in the first group (historical players) clearly contributes to making these brands unable to make trust claims. By emphasising their conformity with the market’s norms and values, the historical actors reflect their competitors’ efforts to appear as legitimate watchmakers. This highlights a clear struggle for trust in the market, which constrains both newcomers and jewellery, haute couture and accessories brands to deploy other repertoires to build their social standing. Whereas newcomers heavily mobilise the reputation repertoire, showcasing the technical performance of their products, jewellery, haute couture and accessories brands mobilise superficial status cues that are poorly connected to the market. Furthermore, the finding that historical actors can access more repertoires and a richer set of cues than other categories of brands helps to enrich recent discussions suggesting that brands that enjoy a significant heritage and include it in their value propositions and identities benefit from distinct possibilities and increased opportunities to foster consumer loyalty and satisfaction. Their presence at the spatio-temporal origin of the market allows them to maintain and protect their heritage, which, in the context of this study, takes the form of an overemphasis on market codes and values.
Third, the results also contribute to the stream of research investigating the role of communication in brand building, particularly in the luxury field.
Communication “is central to creating brand meaning, endowing brands with symbolic values and embedding them in their wider sociocultural context”. The authors show how watch brands use their print advertising to build and achieve a distinctive social standing in the watch market.
These findings echo and complement conclusions that luxury houses use their advertising campaigns not only to promote their products but also to convey luxury identity values, such as authenticity, beauty and heritage.
What the authors’ data suggest, however, is that these values are not equally mobilised by, or accessible to, all brands. The authors made an important contribution by suggesting that, even within a group of brands belonging to the same sector (that is, fine watchmaking), there are nuances and, sometimes, important differences in the way these luxury brands present themselves. The results revealed that luxury brands, despite their high social standing, remain constrained by their market embeddedness.
For example, the data showed that the notion of authenticity can only be fully mobilised by historical brands, which can emphasise their expertise and creativity over time and thus become transgenerational references.
Likewise, we found differences in the way brands use celebrities, an important means of building brand value. Although historical brands use a variety of brand ambassadors, such as historical figures, recently deceased celebrities or less famous individuals (for example, the founders or owners of the brands), the other players mainly mobilise contemporary “mainstream” celebrities.
Practical implications
This research also has implications for practice in terms of how brands signal their social standing in markets and, in particular, in seeking or defending their trust. Being or appearing legitimate in the market is of paramount importance.
As previous research has shown, trust implies greater consumer support, increased purchase intentions and better returns on new products.
This study suggests, however, that acquiring or maintaining trust is a complex undertaking, as the following anecdote shows: when Montblanc, a German brand that produces luxury writing instruments, announced in 1997 its entry into the wristwatch market, the CEO at the time was confronted with questions from journalists such as “How do you put the ink in the watch?”, in a direct challenge to the trust in the brand extension.
New brands, such as those in the third group, suffer by definition from the liability of newness when launching their activities. As such, they cannot leverage any pre-existing brand equity and must build their positioning from scratch.
A valid strategy, as this study illustrates, is:
to invest in technical performance, since technical mastery was at the origin of the mechanical fine watchmaking market.
Richard Mille, for example, which was founded in 2001, stood out in the field through its innovative materials and technologies, as well as through the presentation of its products’ technical performance. The brand’s strategy allowed it to gain status and a reputation that made up for its original lack of trust, to the point where the brand was recognised as a key actor and invited to take part in exclusive professional fine watchmaking programmes.
Established brands that extend their activities into a new market, such as those in the fourth group, also suffer from the liability of newness, since brand extension strategies have to be perceived as legitimate in order to succeed. In contrast with newcomers, these brands often benefit from strong brand equity in their home market.
Therefore, a valid strategy may be to explicitly leverage this pre-existing brand equity through brand extensions.
The authors noted, surprisingly, that the brands in our sample made little use of this strategy, with the exception of Van Cleef & Arpels, which makes explicit references to high jewellery, its main market.
Other strategies include partnering with or acquiring a legitimate actor. Montblanc, for example, acquired the Minerva manufacture in 2006 and successfully entered the fine watch market, relying heavily on the long and recognised heritage of this Swiss manufacturer, which had been producing watches since 1858. The quest for trust was so important that it even led Montblanc to engage in a highly ambiguous discourse about its involvement in watchmaking.
On its website, the brand states: “The Montblanc watchmaking tradition began 160 years ago, in 1858”. However, the brand’s first watch was actually produced in 1997, and the “tradition” referred to is the one developed by the Minerva Manufacture.
Finally, although the market players who master the values and norms they helped to build benefit from established positions, they may always see these positions challenged or threatened by newcomers intent on changing the rules of the game.
For example, the arrival of smartwatches in 2015 profoundly affected the fine watchmaking market, shifting its boundaries, with a direct impact on the position of fine watchmaking brands in the market. Brands with low market embeddedness can seize the opportunity of such a technological innovation to disrupt the established order, as is the case with Louis Vuitton and Montblanc, which launched their smartwatches in 2017.
To defend themselves against such threats, a successful strategy may consist of strengthening the importance of the market’s fundamental values and norms and the constellation of meanings that accompany them.
By influencing representations of what a typical fine watchmaking brand should look like, fine watchmaking brands can make it harder for new or outside brands to position themselves in this market.
--
This is a very recent study with a hugely important contribution for new Portuguese brands. You can leave your comment on this article; all comments are very welcome. To support these and other articles, join the Clube IPR:





Comments