top of page

The Watch Bubble

1 hour ago
5 min read
Collectors have surely all talked among themselves about the bubble that is always about to burst. These rumours and predictions crop up in the most diverse fields and usually serve to deal with the fear of catastrophe. Could this be a possible scenario in the watch market?

Image generated by Dall.E 2 from the prompt "a bubble with a wrist watch inside, digital art"
Image generated by Dall.E 2 from the prompt "a bubble with a wrist watch inside, digital art"

"Bubbles" usually result from a sudden rise in the prices of goods, caused by some kind of economic, political or social change. As these new values do not reflect the real price, the bubble tends to "burst". The result is that prices fall substantially in a short period of time and, often, it can take years for them to return to "pre-bubble" levels. However, not every increase in value implies a financial bubble. There can be a permanent growth in the value of these goods.


In watchmaking, as in other fields, a repeating pattern can be found. There are recessions and global events that reduce purchasing power; however, things normally improve progressively and, in the end, purchasing power increases. Then the brands increase production, the economy falls again, and a surplus of watches builds up in shops and factories, which leads to big discounts and the growth of grey markets. At this point, it all starts again.



The present day


At present there is Russia's invasion of Ukraine, which entails astronomical costs for many countries, sums that necessarily have to be spent but which, in a different scenario, could have been invested in other sectors. Then there is the rise in prices all over the world due to fuel and food shortages, possibly causing large-scale recessions. And let us not forget COVID-19 which, although its impact has lessened, is still being felt in some countries, especially in China. Everything suggests that these factors make up a storm conducive to a free fall in watch prices.



Back to the past


The last crisis of the Swiss watch industry was not related to wars or recessions; as we all know, it was related to quartz crystals.

However, just as photography did not kill painting, quartz watches did not destroy mechanical watchmaking.

The rise in demand after the quartz crisis led brands to increase production and invest in state-of-the-art machines and equipment to make more and more watches for less and less money. Highly skilled watchmakers became less sought after as they were gradually replaced by assembly-line workers. Instead of selling exclusive, high-quality watches, brands relied more and more on extravagant marketing campaigns. Research and development was often relegated to the background.


Swiss watch exports in number of units have fallen steadily over the last decade, from a high of approximately 30 million in 2011 (29.8 million) to just over 20 million (20.6 million) last year.



What has changed?

Hublot Big Bang Unico Sapphire Baguettes
Hublot Big Bang Unico Sapphire Baguettes

Although the perfect storm of global turbulence is gathering over the watch industry, there are many ways to find hope. While watches in the low and mid-range market sectors have struggled for many years, high-end watch brands continue to make their way very well.


2021 was the strongest year ever for the Swiss watch industry. Export values reached €21,380 million, slightly surpassing the 2014 record and comfortably ahead of pre-Covid levels. Although the number of watches shipped from Switzerland fell by three per cent in 2022, their value rose by 12%. And high-end watches outperformed all other sectors.


According to the 2022 Deloitte Swiss Watch Industry Study, “stronger growth is forecast for watch retail in the €5,000 – €25,000 segment, as well as for the > €25,000 segment, while growth in mid-range watches is expected to stagnate. Watches up to €1,000 are also expected to decline next year – this segment competes more directly with smartwatches and with their foreign counterparts.”



Not everything is worse thanks to Covid-19


Just as the quartz crisis led to the transformation and rebirth of the mechanical watch industry, the COVID-19 crisis led to an explosion in demand for high-quality watches. The global market for expensive mechanical watches grew, and the potential market did not simply grow like a helium balloon at a children's birthday party, it grew like an enormous weather balloon. People with bulging wallets and without the traditional outlets for their spending, such as travel and expensive restaurants, among others, shifted their buying impulses to the online market and, among other products, bought watches. They did not only shop online: with more time on their hands, and also thanks to working from home, they read more and researched more online. As most online watch articles cover the most popular brands and watches, these were the ones that quickly sold out, creating even more exclusivity, which drove even greater demand.


However, it was not only the most popular watch brands that saw an increase in demand; the same happened with independent watchmakers' brands, which until then had been practically unknown to the world at large.

Returning to the lower export figures (by volume) in 2022, together with the higher-value overall export figures, there is hope that the big brands have learnt to control overproduction and, even if they have not, there is hope that excess demand will largely make up for a market slowdown.



What about the independents?

URWERK UR-106 Flower Power
URWERK UR-106 Flower Power

Independent watchmakers are in an even stronger position to weather the slowdown. For many, if not most, demand far exceeds their production capacity. Many do not just have long waiting lists, they have closed waiting lists. Even if demand for the smaller brands were to halve, this would probably just shorten the waiting lists, not eliminate them.


The greatest risk for the new generation of independents is not finding customers, it is managing success and coping with a lack of experience in handling hard times. Brands such as Urwerk, De Bethune, Grönefeld, F-P. Journe and Greubel Forsey struggled for decades to sell their watches. Even Philippe Dufour had difficulties, in a continual struggle against liquidity and supply problems. The brands that went through hard years learnt the lesson. The new generation of independents does not have that experience in its pocket.


Lest we forget: the secondary market


And then there is the secondary market. In the early days, if you wanted to sell a watch, you went through the buy-and-sell groups that some of the forums had, and that DEZ/DEZ still has, or you hoped to know someone who also knew someone who was interested, or else there were auctions. Now we have many prestigious auction houses holding major watch auctions all over the world, and there are pre-owned platforms such as Watchbox, Chrono24, eBay, Crown & Caliber and many others. Even Rolex has entered this market.


Just as the huge used-car market has helped sales of new cars, the greater liquidity in the growing offer of the pre-owned market makes many more newcomers to the world of fine watchmaking feel more comfortable about taking the first step.

Conclusion

Normally, day follows night; we will certainly see a slowdown in demand for watches when, or rather if, the world economy contracts (again). But will the bubble burst or just let out a little air? No doubt some brands will suffer, especially at the lower end, but it is reckoned that, overall, no deep general fall will be seen. For the independents, all this will probably even mean that they can finally reopen their waiting lists. Just as Rolex boutiques may actually start having watches available to sell!

Do you remember the days when Rolex boutiques actually sold watches? Only time will tell whether it will happen again.


What do you think will happen over the next two years?


Tell us what you think in the comments below.



Further reading:


Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page